Former Wisconsin Safety Justin Taylor to Reenter NCAA Transfer Portal: A Look at the Trend

In the ever-churning landscape of college football, the transfer portal giveth and the portal taketh away. For the second time in his young career, former Wisconsin Badgers safety Justin Taylor is betting on himself in the open market. According to a report from 247Sports’ Allen Trieu, Taylor plans to reenter the NCAA transfer portal after one season with the Wyoming Cowboys. This move not only highlights Taylor’s personal journey for the right fit but also underscores a fascinating and growing trend among players who once called Madison home. With two years of eligibility remaining, Taylor’s decision adds another chapter to the complex narrative of modern roster construction.

From Madison to Laramie and Beyond: Justin Taylor’s Journey

Justin Taylor’s collegiate path is a testament to patience and persistence. A three-star recruit from La Grange Park, Illinois, in the class of 2023, Taylor joined a Wisconsin program known for its defensive prowess. His time as a Badger, however, was measured in limited opportunities. He appeared in just two games during the 2024 season as a redshirt freshman, a stint that concluded with his first entry into the transfer portal.

Seeking a fresh start and a clearer path to the field, Taylor committed to the Wyoming Cowboys. In Laramie, he found the playing time he sought. During the 2025 campaign, Taylor became a contributor in the Cowboys’ secondary, appearing in nine games. His stat line—19 total tackles, 1.5 tackles for loss, two pass deflections, and one interception—proves he can be a productive piece at the FBS level. Yet, after this season of growth, the portal calls again. The search for the perfect schematic fit, NIL landscape, or role continues, a reality for hundreds of players each cycle.

A Growing Wisconsin Exodus: The Re-Entry Trend

What makes Taylor’s story particularly noteworthy is that he is far from alone. He is set to join a growing list of former Wisconsin Badgers who have chosen to reenter the transfer portal after just one year at a new program. This pattern suggests a deeper evaluation of initial transfer decisions and the relentless pursuit of an ideal situation.

• Jonas Duclona (CB): The cornerback transferred from Wisconsin to Colorado, only to reenter the portal after the 2025 season.
• Braedyn Locke (QB): The quarterback left Madison for a chance elsewhere, but is now back in the portal seeking his next stop.
• Mabrey Mettauer (QB): Another signal-caller who departed Wisconsin, Mettauer is also on the move again after a single season at his new school.

This trend raises questions. Are players leaving Wisconsin with incomplete information about their next destination? Is the grass not always greener, prompting a second look? Or is this simply the new normal, where the portal is a perpetual tool for roster management from both the player and program perspective? The common thread is a continued belief in one’s own potential, even after a first transfer doesn’t yield the dreamed-of results.

Expert Analysis: What Taylor’s Move Means for the Market

From a roster-building standpoint, Justin Taylor presents an intriguing case for defensive coordinators. He is no longer a project based on high school film; he is a known commodity with verified FBS experience. His 2025 tape at Wyoming shows a player capable of making plays. The interception and pass breakups demonstrate ball skills, while his tackle numbers indicate a willingness to be involved in run support.

Taylor’s two years of remaining eligibility are a significant asset. A program can bring him in not as a one-year rental, but as a player who can learn the system for a year and be a cornerstone the following season. He fits the profile of a player who could thrive in a Group of Five conference seeking an immediate starter, or a Power Four program looking for experienced depth and special teams acumen with upside.

The broader trend of “re-transfers” signals a maturation of the portal era. The first wave was chaotic, with players often jumping at the first opportunity. Now, we may be entering a phase of strategic recalibration. Players like Taylor have the benefit of portal experience; they know the drill, understand the timelines, and can be more targeted in their approach. For coaches, it means evaluating players not just on their original recruiting pedigree, but on their most recent college performance—a more accurate, if transient, measure of value.

Predictions: Where Could Justin Taylor Land?

Forecasting a transfer destination is an imperfect science, but based on profile and need, several paths emerge for Taylor. His Midwest roots and previous Wisconsin tenure could make him attractive to other Big Ten programs seeking defensive back depth, especially those transitioning defensive schemes. A return closer to home in Illinois might also be a factor.

More likely, Taylor could aim for a program where the path to a starting safety job is clearest. This often points to competitive Group of Five schools or Power Four programs that lost key veterans in the secondary. Look for teams that run defensive schemes similar to Wyoming’s or Wisconsin’s, where Taylor’s skill set in zone coverage and coming downhill against the run would require less adjustment. His decision will be a key indicator of whether he prioritizes conference prestige or guaranteed playing time as he heads into the final stages of his college career.

Conclusion: The Portal’s Perpetual Motion

Justin Taylor’s journey from Wisconsin to Wyoming and back into the transfer portal is a microcosm of college football’s new reality. It is a story of adaptation, resilience, and the continuous quest for the right opportunity. The fact that he is part of a cohort of former Badgers making a second portal jump highlights a systemic shift: player movement is no longer a one-time event but an ongoing strategy.

For fans, it requires a shift in perspective. Players like Taylor are not merely leaving; they are navigating a complex ecosystem to build their careers and educations. For programs, it underscores the need to not only recruit high school talent but to expertly manage and retain their roster in an environment of perpetual free agency. As the portal windows open and close, the career of Justin Taylor reminds us that in today’s game, a player’s path is rarely a straight line—it’s a series of calculated leaps, each aimed at finding that perfect fit.

Stay updated on all Wisconsin Badgers transfer portal news and coverage by following @TheBadgersWire on X (formerly Twitter) and liking our page on Facebook.

Source: Based on news from Yahoo Sports.